May 4, 2008
This table is a format for me to develop ideas for creating a small animation on the amplitude (size) of the harmonics on the vibrating strings of guitar chords. (wave equation/pde) The shifting, interwoven patterns created and implied by these harmonics are an essential part of the music played on the instrument and their amplitude, size (or strength) is probably best described here with calculus (If it can be simplified beyond what I have done so far - "Calculus 2" animation) I don't think the subject should be avoided on this website, the question is how to make it most presentable in animation format. I expect that much of the information here will not be explicit in the animation, but taken into consideration so as to avoid significant error. |
||
| Quote | Source | Comments |
| ... | ... | There are somewhat contradictory Musemath objectives here: 1. First, whatever is done should fit the subject of (guitar and string) and be of some interest to a practicing musician. 2. Supplement (at least not interfere with) the education of those persuing the subject. It seems to me, at this time, any small improvement in any of these things may be worth a great deal of effort. The internet may multiply the effects to the general advantage of all.
|
In spite of the pressures to take calculus while still in high school, students should never short-change their mathematical preparation in subjects such as algebra, geometry, or trigonometry. Solid mathematical preparation is far more important than exposure to calculus. |
http://www.maa.org/features
|
Treating calculus as the language of science; 1. What is basic fluency in it? 2. How is fluency obtained? *** The subject takes some work. and significant preparation. I am looking at the following 2 sites to bolster my agebra: |
| HS AP Calculus Curriculum | http://www.collegeboard.com /student/testing/ap/prep.html |
In general, the U.S. standards for "Advance Placement" in math for (I'm guessing) 14-17 year old students. I'm treating the general comprehension of most of this material (regardless of when it is actually learned) as a sort of basic literacy for 'science specialists'. It is more than should or will be covered in Musemath but may provide me with a sort of guideline to the understanding of people who know more than I do. Hopefully it will help me avoid blatant error. |
In mathematics, partial differential equations (PDE) are a type of differential equation, i.e., a relation involving an unknown function (or functions) of several independent variables and its (resp. their) partial derivatives with respect to those variables. Partial differential equations are used to formulate, and thus aid the solution of, problems involving functions of several variables; such as the propagation of sound or heat, electrostatics, electrodynamics, fluid flow, elasticity. Interestingly, seemingly distinct physical phenomena may have identical mathematical formulations, and thus be governed by the same underlying dynamic. |
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki /Partial_differential_equation |
Partial Differential Equation:.
For all the above discussion, the end result is likely to be simply a Partial Differential Equation:.
|
Vibrating string
u(t, 0) = 0, u(t, L) = 0, u(t, x) = f(x), u [sub t](0, x) = g(x), The method of separation of variables for the wave equation u[sub tt] = c^2 u[sub xx], leads to solutions of the form u(t, x) = T(t)X(x), where T^n + (k^2)(c^2)T = 0 k= n(pi)/L, where n is an integer. Each term in the sum corresponds to a mode of vibration of the string. The mode with n=1 is called the fundamental mode, and the frequencies of the other modes are all multiples of this frequency. They form the overtone series of the string, and they are the basis for musical acoustics. The initial conditions may then be satisfied by representing f and g as infinite sums of these modes... |
Wikipedia, ibid | Specifically, the 'Wave Equation" for a... Vibrating string Fourier Series, Fourier Integral, and Boundrry Conditions are important here and at least mentioned in the article. |
| I'm looking for helpful historical explanations at the following sites; | ||
... Newton claimed that his method of fluxions was conceived in 1665. Its fullest treatment is in De methodis fluxionum et serierum infinitorum, dated 1671... which was actually a letter that was never meant to be published. |
http://www.math.rutgers.edu Isaac Newton Kerry Kijewski History of Mathematics Term Paper, Rutgers, Spring 1999
|
This gives some dates and titles, some helpful explanations of Newton's conception of calculus, and suggestions for further reading.
|
| The starting point was that geometrical magnitudes arise from continuous motion... In other words, a line or curve is generated by the continuous motion of a point, a surface by the motion of a line and a solid by the motion of a surface...Newton called the line a "fluent" because he thought of it as a flowing quantity ... The fluxion, or rate at which it flowed, was the point's velocity .[5, p.213] Dotted letters were used to represent the fluxions. These fluxions could, in turn, be taken as fluents and this led to higher order fluxions, which were represented by two dots. There is an obvious relation: the velocity of a point determines the nature of the curve, and a curve of a given nature can only be generated by a point with a certain velocity...two problems arose: given a relationship between fluents, how one can determine the corresponding relationship between fluxions, and the inverse, how one can determine fluents on the basis of fluxions...These processes are known today as differentiation and integration. | Kijewski, ibid | Some of the Newtonian explanations here might be animated to give some idea of his approach. In general his work may be better suited to animated demonstrations but Leibniz' formal symbolic calculus is the accepted form today. Where possible they might be compared in animation. |
Scholium "The foundation of the general method is contained in the preceding Lemma." |
Newton's `Principia': http://www.maths.tcd.ie/pub
|
These are I believe Newton's own final words on the subject, from his own revised edition of the Principa written with half a century of reflection. The book is generally considered the most important work in science, from within its framework. an image of our place in the material world has been drawn. |
By 1676, Leibniz had invented the notation that made calculus easy to learn and apply: dy/dx , INT y and INT y dx . The first account of this appears in Nova methodus... published in his own scientific journal Acta Eruditorum in 1684. By 1690, Leibniz had discovered most of the ideas of elementary calculus, including differential equations, but he did not write up a complete treatment of this material, which was first done by L'Hospital (1651--1704) and Jean Bernoulli (1667--1748). |
http://www.maths.uwa.edu.au /~schultz/3M3/L19Leibniz.html |
There is some excellent historical treatment of the subject on this site, This apparently translates some of Leibniz's original discussions. Here is an animation (currently little more than a placeholder - eventually it may explore some ways to make the explanations a bit more appropriate for the NetAge. |
Mathematical for Descartes was what could be grasped in a single intuition or could be reduced in clearly understood steps to such immediate apprehension.
|
http://www.princeton.edu INFINITESIMALS AND TRANSCENDENT Michael S. Mahoney
|
04/17/08 Descarte's ideas of visual mechanical linkages as logical steps is discussed a bit in Origins 12TET 2, page 29 and Origins 12TET 3, page 14 . Apparently, in 1637 it was most important for Descarte to demonstrate the validity of the new algebraic operations by picturing them in terms of well known, existing geometrical methods. |
|
|
|
"A quantitative relation," wrote Leibniz, (11) "is a way of finding one quantity by means of another", and, as will become clear below, an equation of whatever degree constituted a modus inveniendi. (modus inveniendi - a way of discovery) ...Taking algebraic equations as themselves basically intelligible, he moved to widen the concept of the equation by shifting focus from the notion of a compound relation to that of a modus inveniendi, a way of finding (one quantity by means of others), thereby encompassing the new, transcendent relations that were so interesting both mathematically and physically.
|
Mahoney Ibid. |
|
citing J.E. Hofmann "... Leibniz strove for a technique of representation which is simplified and formalized down to the [detail] by means of appropriate symbols, yet which cannot be immediately grasped but must be learned. Whoever can acquire this has an unimaginable advantage over the uninititated, even when he has no particularly deep insights into the connections: the formalism thinks for him.
|
Mahoney Ibid | My thinking is that the animations, and probably to a greater extent their actual construction by students in some software program provides some of the useful "insights and connections." That's pretty much the way I think I'm learning this stuff - along with this historical approach. (and I still need to try making up for some formal education lapses by going to the basic problem oriented math courses). |
That the straight and the curved coalesced at the level of the infinitesimal was a premiss of the calculus, indeed its raison d'être.
|
Mahoney Ibid | "Ghosts of departed quantities" and a need for the Limit concept. |
,,, Newton and Leibniz knew how to correctly give the derivatives of most common functions, but they did not have a precise definition of "derivative"; they could not actually prove the theorems that they were using. .... They explained a derivative as a quotient of two infinitesimals (i.e., infinitely small but nonzero numbers).
Ultimately, the biggest difference between the infinitesimal approach and the epsilon-delta approach is in what kind of language you use to hide the quantifiers: The numbers epsilon and delta are "ordinary-sized", in the sense that they are not infinitely small. They are moderately small, e.g., numbers like one billionth. We look at what happens when we vary these numbers and make them smaller. In effect, these numbers are changing, so there is motion or action in our description. We can make these numbers smaller than any ordinary positive number that has been chosen in advance.
|
http://www.math.vanderbilt.edu /~schectex/courses/whystudy.html |
|
| The differential form was adopted by continental mathematicians. The application of it by Euler, Lagrange, and Laplace to the principles of mechanics laid down in the Principia was the great achievement of the last half of (...the 18th) century, and finally demonstrated the superiority of the differential to the fluxional calculus. | http://www.maths.tcd.ie/pub D.R. Wilkins |
|
...Euler published his differential calculus book, Institutiones calculi differentialis... in 1755. ...Euler is stuck with the paradox that the quantity dx is, in some sense, both zero and
|
http://www.maa.org/editorial How Euler Did It |
I have not gone very deeply into this material. (at all) Jerome Keisler's book on Non-Standard Calculus is now available on-line (free, April 18, 2008) |
| Perhaps this exchange will remind us that the rigorous basis for the calculus is not at all intuitive—in fact, quite the contrary. The calculus is a subject dealing with speeds and distances, with tangents and areas—not inequalities. |
http://mrfronius.com Who Gave You the Epsilon? Cauchy and the Origins of Rigorous Calculus Judith V. Grabiner, |
|
| The early teachers at the École Polytechnique set a precedent of writing textbooks and Cauchy followed the tradition. He wrote three texts on Calculus, in 1821, 1823 and 1829, and they set the pattern which nearly all calculus texts have followed to this day - definitions of limits and of continuous and differentiable functions, numerous graphical and analytic examples and exercises, simple applications, definite integration, d.e's. He didn't define real numbers or functions, but he did have dependent and independent variables. He defined derivatives as the limit of the difference quotient... | http://www.maths.uwa.edu Lecture 27 The Calculus of Cauchy. Phill Schultz |
|
| Eventually, in the 19th century, mathematicians became aware of some subtle oversights in the logic that had been accepted until then, and found that epsilon-delta arguments were the best way to fix these problems. |
"Need a simple explanation for the calculus concept of limit, especially delta and epsilon" |
|
Karl Theodor Wilhelm Weierstrass 1815 – 1897 At the time, there were ambiguous definitions regarding the fundamentals of calculus, hence theorems could not be properly proven. While Bolzano had developed a reasonably rigorous definition of a limit as early as 1817 (and possibly even earlier) his work remained unknown to most of the mathematical community until years later, and other eminent mathematicians such as Cauchy had only vague definitions of limits and continuity of functions. ... |
http://en.wikipedia.org /wiki/Karl_Weierstrass |
|
SOME CALCULUS SITES AND SOURCES |
||
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/Hbase/calc.html#calch http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/Hbase/hmat.html#hmath Ron Nave |
Generally indispensible to me for its clear content and ease of navigation. You can find and cross check things quickly. | |
http://www.mc.maricopa.edu David Schultz, http://www.mc.maricopa.edu/
|
Limit Animations were immediately helpful to me. Caveat, links to class websies sometimes dissapear, either because they were never intended for the non-paying non-student or possibly just because the class ended. |
|
| This site is an online supplement to Math 100, Sections 103, 104, 107 and 109, being taught within the University of British Columbia Department of Mathematics. Everyone is welcome and feedback is appreciated. | http://www.ugrad.math.ubc.ca /coursedoc/math100/index.html |
UBC Calculus Online. |
http://archives.math.utk.edu |
Two sites for ideas developing a calculus animation suitable for Musemath | |
Preface P273...The idea of a functional relationship was more or less identified with the existence of a simple mathematical formula expressing the exact relationship. This concept proved too narrow for the requirements of mathematical physics... |
What is Mathematics?: An Elementary Approach To Ideas and Numbers By Richard Courant, Herbert Robbins -
Contributor Ian Stewart .
|
A principle source for some time. On re-reading a number of ideas seem to have been implanted, even if not understood on first reading. (Or in many cases on second and probably future readings for that matter - though at this point I can pretty much just look for sections that are insufficiently annotated.) |
Eutocius/Eratosthenes description of mesolabium. There are 2nd hand descriptions but the original may be needed for the linkage (if it exists). Many original works are not yet on the internet. This is the location of most complete second hand description I have found so far- it is possible some of the unavailable sections have the actual letter |
The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems
|
I'm looking to verify some concepts of "Linkage" such as used by Descartes and possibly somewhat differently in the Mesolabium animation, Origins 12TET 3 I'm satisfied with an approximate solution and the idea of a steam locomotive piston was exactly what came to mind when I thought of the linkage used in the animation. Perhaps something else is needed for greater precision: http://kmoddl.library. How to Draw a Straight Line (see also http://www.math.ru On the other hand, with virtual mechanisms, the simplest linkage to transmit the idea quickly seems to me the best demonstration technique. (followed perhaps by a "virtual footnote" on the problem) - If a good description by Eratoshenes exists I may be able to avoid the complication. Apparently the "mechanistic" approach was supplanted by Leibniz' "modus inveniendi", a way of finding (one quantity by means of others) as noted above, and perhaps later by a more refined notion of function but it would be nice to get this linkage idea correctly explained.. |
Calculus First impression of these sites - the concern is whether they can help me, i.e. outside the classroom. http://www.math.hmc.edu Online Mathematics Tutorials at Harvey Mudd College! http://math.smith.edu/Local/cicintro/cicintro.html The story of the Five College Calculus Project began almost forty years ago, when the Five Colleges were only Four: Amherst, Mount Holyoke, Smith, and the large Amherst campus of the University of Massachusetts. PDF format - not reviewed - what I'm lookoing for is quick transmission of good, organized information - There are some PDF links below but they sounded and turned out to be more appropriate for me. http://web01.shu.edu Interactive Real Analysis is an online, interactive textbook for Real Analysis or Advanced Calculus in one real variable. biographies good - Map navigation good (v similar to "Hyperphysics" > 4.1 Series and Convergence > trouble getting to the punchline of 4.1.1 Zeno - Achilles/tortoise - on second look clicked on small ? Icon got: "The problem with Zeno's paradox is that Zeno was uncomfortable with adding infinitely many numbers. In fact, his basic argument was: if you add infinitely many numbers, then - no matter what those numbers are - you must get infinity. If that was true, it would take Achilles infinitely long to reach the tortoise, and he would loose the race. However, reducing the infinite addition to the limit of a sequence, we have seen that this argument is false." good for animation of "Limit" ?? ___________________ http://www-cm.math.uiuc.edu/what not reviewed - need to buy Mathematica software ____________ http://www.math.harvard.edu gone The Calculus Consortium (at Harvard) a reform movement, some criticisms, books and material for sale - no online course found _____________ Calculus, Concepts, Computers and Cooperative Learning (C4L) gone http://www.math.purdue.edu/~ccc/ http://www.pnc.edu/Faculty _____________ 8. Project CALC (Duke) http://www.math.duke.edu Not reviewed due to: In a number of places we use animations, video clips, sound files, and Flash applets. try at school Material starts here ______________ 9. Calculus from Graphical, Numerical, and Symbolic Points of View (Ostebee and Zorn, St. Olaf College) http://www.stolaf.edu textbook, nothing found online ________________ 10. JPCalculus The Java Powered Calculus Project gone http://www.usm.maine.edu The page that you requested is not available at this address. _______________ 11. Why Slopes and More Math, A Calculus Primer & Companion by A.Selby gone ___________ 12. The Interactive Textbook for PFP 98 http://dept.physics.upenn.edu Some decent introductory language - physics oriented - written material ok but requires Maple software for problems example: ________________ 13. Tutorial - Java Powered EXCELLENT on-line interactive tutorial - Java and Javascript resources. Many excellent real-world explanations and examples. (originally associated w/ Hofstra University) new URL Finite Mathematics & Applied Calculus Resource Page _________________ 14. From Projects to Themes: The Evolution of Calculus Classes at New Mexico State University http://www.math.nmsu.edu ________________ 15. Calculus@Internet http://calculus.sjdccd.cc.ca.us/ ________________ 16. calculus@internet (a service of WebPrimitives Cambridge, Mass) http://www.distancecalculus.com/ selling COURSE OFFERINGS, no material _____________________ 17. Calculus on the Web (Temple University- web problem sets/tutorials) COW An internet tutoring utility for learning and practicing calculus. COW gives the student or interested user the opportunity to learn and practice problems. includes some preCalc COW is a project of ____________________ 18. Interactive Learning in Calculus and Differential Equations (IUP) http://www.ma.iup.edu/projects Requires Mathematica software - I require Flash and Java Applets, I want to avoid anything more than that. The Mathematics Department at Indiana University of Pennsylvania (IUP) established a computerized learning environment, consisting of a classroom with 31 Macintosh Centris 650s and a laboratory with 12 Macintosh LCs, all equipped with Mathematica. ____________________ 19. Calculus Reform at Cornell http://math.cornell.edu gone - Internet Explorer cannot display the webpage _______________ 20.The Connected Curriculum Project: Frank Wattenberg et al.'s grand vision of learning (including calculus) using the www. These three sites are co-linked as well. Connected Curriculum Project -- Duke Connected Curriculum Project -- Montana State _________________ http://www.edwardspenney.com seems pretty commercial w/following interesting link to HS math pg which includes student outline of the couse and some of their annonymous letters to future students The following links will send you to a section in the book which has been outlined by a group of three students from the 1999 and 2000 Kentridge AP Calculus Lab classes. What you will find is their perception of the section, along with ideas which may help you understand each topic. Each section also comes with a practice problem which will (hopefully) challenge you. The problem and it's solution were also developed by each group of students. The work has not yet been checked so readers should be warned that some problems or solutions may be inaccurate! Student outline of the KR Calculus Book (I never did this stuff myself and there are no students about so this is about as close as I get to what's going on in high schools.) _________________ 23. Cengage Learning - commercial http://academic.cengage.com/ Thomson Learning Announces New Name – CENGAGE Learning selling books - no access to free material mathematics page ______________________ 24. Calculus Modules OnLine (PWS OnLine Series) - Brooks/Cole Publishing Company http://www.brookscole.com I made no notes here so it will be looked at again. 25. Thomson Learning Mathematics Resources gone > see 23 above ____________ 26. S.O.S. Math - Calculus http://www.sosmath.com http://www.sosmath.com/calculus/series/intro/intro.html derivative intro not too bad - can simpler formulae be used?? sequence, differentiation, limit, intros confusing http://www.sosmath.com http://www.sosmath.com Note that we will need the complex form of Fourier series of a periodic function. Let us define this object first:... VERYgoodLookingLinksPage _________________________________________ MoreLinks ________________ http://www.ima.umn.edu These are excerpts from a collection of graphical demonstrations I developed for first year calculus. Those interested in higher math may also want to visit my page of graphics for complex analysis. This page is on the list of the most frequently linked math pages according to MathSearch. "...e is the only number for which the tangent to the graph of y=ex through the point (0,1) has slope exactly 1. The important result that the function f(x)=ex is its own derivative follows easily from this fact and the elementary laws of exponents..." java version (not working for me 5/2/08) http://www.hoye.net/index.htm more like tai chi than weight training - I didn't go for it at first try Karl's Calculus Tutor There are dozens of problems worked out for you step-by-step... There is also remedial coverage of algebra topics, number systems, exponentials, logs, trig functions and trigonometry, http://www.karlscalculus.org/why.html http://www.karlscalculus.org/calc3_0.html more links http://homepages.roadrunner.com *** ______________________ http://www.sci.wsu.edu IDEA is Internet Differential Equations Activities, an interdisciplinary effort to provide students and teachers around the world with computer based activities for differential equations in a wide variety of disciplines. NO: models of fish populations etc. - and outdated http://mathforum.org The Forum's Internet Mathematics Library provides a page of links to Calculus Reform resources. A few selections from these pages are offered below. ______________ http://www.ies.co.jp Trig Java AppletsExcellent Java applets that dynamically illustrate trigonometry.(International Education Software) (check out the Fourier applet) _______________ Math 1002 calculus at University Of Aberdeen: Calculus Notes from Ian Craw. http://www.maths.abdn.ac.uk VeryGoodNotes (I downloaded pdf version but suggest use html for ease of navigation) GoodQuote "Experience shows that very few people are able to use lecture notes as a substitute for revision pg 4 ...The weakness of the triangle definition of the trig functions is that it only makes sense Draw the circle x2 + y2 = 1 of radius 1 with centre at the origin. Let OX be the radius along the positive x-axis. P = (cos theta; sin theta) _____________ http://lc.brooklyn.cuny.edu/smarttutor/precalc/index.html Copyright © Brooklyn Didn't make any notes - will look again ______________ http://mathforum.org The Best resources The Math Forum - Math Library - Pre-Calculus Animated Math Glossary - Math Advantage - Harcourt Brace School Publishers http://www.harcourtschool.com A K-8 glossary of common mathematical terms, categorized by grade. Each entry has an example, most of which are animated. An "other" section at the end of the alphabet gives tables of metric and customary measurements, time, formulas, and symbols __________ This site is composed of many math "fill-in-forms" into which you can type the math problem you're working on. Linked to these forms is a powerful set of math-solvers, that can instantly analyze your problem, and when possible, provide you with a step-by-step solution, instantly! ________________ http://www.brunnermath.com excellent links by topic http://www.mathsnet.net/asa2/2004/c1.html vGood but: http://www.mathsnetalevel.com/ Need to take another look at the old site _____________ http://www.mathsnet.net/asa2/2004/c1.html No notes on this one, will take another look. ______________ http://mathmistakes.info/index.html Seems helpful to me - took a bit of playing around to get the idea - explanation immediately helpful - Since I make all kinds of mistakes the URL is to the homepage rather than to just the calculus mistakes page... _____________ http://www.ifigure.com/math/calculus/calculus.htm calculator links - some math tutorials?? Needs another look. ____________________ http://www.netn.net/27111.htm#MATH National Education Telecommunications Network MATHEMATICS more links ____________ http://www.understandingcalculus.com/index.php I've linked here before then deleted -throughout I find ideas I can use surrounded by diiscussions I don't want - will take another look - I think some of the ideas can be usefully abbreviated for my purposes...??? Understanding Calculus is a complete online introductory book that focuses on concepts. Preface A student must be able to understand how to set up an integral in a practical situation be it from electromagnetic forces to dynamic response of a skyscraper during an earthquake. Calculus is an utterly useless tool without this fundamental understanding of what integration is all about as the student will be able to play with Calculus but he or she will never know how to use it...the entire book is unique and has almost no connection to the modern textbook. ____________ http://eqworld.ipmnet.ru/ The international scientific-educational website EqWorld...seems somewhat above me... http://eqworld.ipmnet.ru ______________ http://www.math-atlas.org The Mathematical Atlas is a collection of articles about aspects of mathematics at and above the university level, but (usually) not at the level of current research. The goal of this collection is to introduce the subject areas of modern mathematics, to describe a few of the milestone results and topics, and to give pointers to some of the key resources where further information is to be found. Like any good atlas, we try to present several ways to look at each area and to show its relationship with neighboring areas and sub-areas. Last modified 2002/03/14 by Dave Rusin |
||
Some miscellaneous stuff I just want to get off the Update Page:
__________________________________________________________
http://www.math.tamu.edu/~dallen/history/euclid/euclid.html, The Elements an excellent illustrated overview which may contain all or most of what I need for my purposes
___________________________________________________________
Doubling the cube amounts to finding the cube root of two, that is, ... solving a cubic equation. Why Trisecting the Angle is Impossible...trisecting an angle amounts to solving a cubic equation. ...So algebraically, the two constructions are equivalent
____________________________________________________________
http://www.math.utoronto.ca/mathnet/questionCorner/impossconstruct.html
...if you start with some initial points whose coordinates are all rational numbers, then apply any sequence of compass-and-straightedge construction techniques, the coordinates of the points you end up with will be a very special kind of number: they will be obtainable from the rational numbers by a sequence of operations involving only addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and the extraction of square roots.
The reason the three classical constructions (ror - 2x cube + 3x angle [+sqCircle]) are impossible is that they are asking you to be able to construct points whose coordinates are not numbers of this type.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------http://www.math.sfu.ca/histmath/math380notes/math380.html
The Greeks were the 1st civilization concerned with proving results, instead of merely calculating them, as previous mathematicians.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://members.cox.net/edremler/Papers/Worldview/Descartes/Text.html
Descarte as Mechanical Philosopher.(The Mechanists, following Francis Bacon (1561-1626), felt ...) that men ought to organize themselves as a sacred duty to improve and transform the conditions of life. In November of 1619, Descartes (1596-1650) met Isaac Beeckman. Six weeks later, Descartes presented Beeckman with a New Years gift: a 40 page essay on the science of music.Music and mechanism were to operate together in Descartes’ mind to bring forth the most important steps in the creation of algebra as well as its fusion with geometry into what is now called analytic geometry. ...Zarlino...had shown how two lines in the ratio 2^1/12:1 could be measured off this ratio directly using a mechanical device, known as a mesolabium that had been invented by Eratosthenes... in the third century BCE...Descartes got the idea for a more practical and versatile variant of the mesolabium which he called a proportional compass. Descartes' Geometry was not about static constructions and axiomatic proofs, but instead concerned itself with mechanical motions and their possible representation in algebraic equations. Descartes sought to build a geometry that included all curves that could be drawn with a mechanical linkage ... this class of curves is exactly the class of all algebraic curves although he gave no formal proof of this.
[Summarized Points]http://www.oswego.edu/multi-campus-nsf/descartes1.htm David Dennis René Descartes' Curve-Drawing Devices:
Experiments in the Relations Between Mechanical Motion and Symbolic Language
Descartes' demonstrated the compatibility of geometrical and algebraic representation...the ability of algebraic language to represent geometry accurately...the results of symbolic algebraic manipulations are consistent with independently established geometrical results. Curves were constructed by the geometrical actions of mechanical apparatuses. After curves had been drawn Descartes introduced coordinates and then analyzed the curve-drawing actions in order to arrive at an equation that represented the curve.Equations did not create curves; curves gave rise to equations...nowhere in the Geometry did he ever graph an equation....he emphasized the importance of making strong connections between physical actions and their possible representations in diagrams and language.
March 6, 2007 updated September 26, 20071. http://physics.ucsc.edu/~michael/pthooke1 (ror - If I succeed with an introductory animation on the calculus of fourier analysis I should certainly like to have some background on the origin of calculus, this article gives some ideas.)
Newton was not yet aware that for central forces, angular momentum is conserved, justifying Kepler's second law (area law)...What Hooke had suggested in 1679 to Newton is that orbital motion could be decomposed into "a direct [inertial] motion by the tangent, and an attractive motion [radial] towards the central body" For a central impulsive force acting at periodic intervals, this decomposition of motion makes the conservation of angular momentum manifest, as Newton subsequently showed in De Motu, his first draft of the Principia.Some more background:
This proof became a cornerstone of the Principia, as Proposition 1 in Book 1, because it permitted him to completely geometrize orbital dynamics by replacing the time variable by the area swept by the radius drawn to the center of force...
http://www.crystalinks.com/boyle.html
The Invisible College refers mainly to the intrinsic ideology of the free transfer of thought and technical expertise,..It is merely an attempt to circumvent bureaucratic or monetary obstacles by knowledgeable individuals and civic groups...In 1663 the Invisible College became the Royal Society of London for the Improvement of Natural Knowledge...______________
http://www.roxie.org/books/shoulders/ch03-labor.html
In 1676, Isaac Newton, in the middle of one of his endless catfights with Robert Hooke, wrote that “If I have seen further it is by standing on ye sholders of Giants.” Most of our books credit him with the saying. But he didn’t make it up. He was quoting an expression common in his day.http://www.uwe.ac.uk/fas/wavelength/wave21/ramsey.html
...Although the letter is couched in outwardly courteous terms, the reference to giants has been seen by many as a direct insult to Hooke. According to his contemporaries John Aubrey and Samuel Pepys, Hooke was short and somewhat unprepossessing in appearance.http://www.discover.com/issues/oct-04/departments/reviews/?page=2
Hooke accused Newton of stealing his ideas about planetary motion and gravity, while Newton was convinced that Hooke was a braggart who made false claims to precedence. Inwood makes a plausible case that there was truth to both claims. Hooke’s ideas may indeed have inspired Newton, but Newton’s brilliant mathematical skills far exceeded Hooke’s, enabling him to move beyond intuition to revolutionary new theories.
July 17, 2006The idea of studying calculus in order to play or listen to guitar music seems a bit excessive. These are some notes to myself as to where I would like to go with this. The guitar involves variations in the strengths of several frequencies sounding simultaneously. Fourier analysis/transform and calculus, provided they can be made brief and to the point, seems the best and shortest way to understanding. With a bit of work it may be possible to create an animation which demonstrates some of the key ideas and which would satisfy the natural curiosity expected in a casual visitor to the website. I am thinking of a rather long term commitment to create a two minute animation for the general public. They may be useful to a musician to the extent they do not interfere with quality practice time and useful to students of science to the extent a solid conceptual foundation is formed as a basis for further study and analogy.
"...a man may have some special knowledge and experience... However, to circulate this little scrap of knowledge, he will undertake to write down the whole of physics. From this vice spring many great abuses." Essays; Of Cannibals
The following sites may have some relevence:
http://www.relisoft.com/Science/Physics/fourier.html
This is a commercial site giving away some information here re: phase and
weighted sums. I'm not ready for most of this but may get something from it. I
haven't yet checked to see what their selling.
http://mathforum.org/library/drmath/view/62097.html
A caution is in order: it is useful to describe musical structures through mathematics, but musical flexibility and creativity surpasses what can be described by simple mathematics. For example, the scale of a wind instrument established by the fingering may be represented through mathematics: but in the hands of a skillful player, the predefined scale serves only as the basis for a more flexible intonation controlled through the embouchure and breath control.
More and more in the course of the 19th century, the significance of enharmonic modulations lay not so much in their momentary effect as in the way they enabled composers to exploit the same physical scale in terms of two systems at once: harmonic and equal-division.
That is, regardless of the future fashion and direction of music, this would seem to be a necessary feature of the standard, off the shelf, 12TET(EDO) guitar. That is, with every sequential note, two distinct lines of logic are being set before the listener. There is an inescapable play between them which can be emphasized or minimized but on such an instrument, not entirely eluded. I find it rather enjoyable and challenging though others may want something else. This is a bit speculative and as imperfect as everything else encountered so far. When I play I think mostly of resolving my current emotional and aesthetic sense, not math formulas.